Sidewalk Safety: Why Property Managers Must Address Hazards Quickly

Share this post

It’s the dead of winter, when the sky gets dark before 6 p.m. and wind chills cause people to tremble uncontrollably. Making matters worse, snow is falling and it doesn’t have an endpoint in mind. This is when thinking ahead can really help you and your short-term future. Being proactive is important, not only for residents in their daily lives but also the managers that look after them and have their well-being in mind. However, sometimes observing a weather report is only helpful to a certain degree. If a foot and a half of snow is set to fall in one’s neighborhood, the best course of action is to stay vigilant and understand how to address the concern.

Recent incidents, including one that led to a particular court case in New Jersey, can better prepare managers for the perils of not being prepared. In the recent New Jersey Supreme Court case “Qian v. Toll Brothers” in August 2015, the court ruled that an association is not immune from liability for personal injuries sustained on a sidewalk which is privately owned by the community association.” The ruling, however, was pretty consistent with common law and related provisions of the Condominium Act and Planned Real Estate Development Full Disclosure Act.

Still, it’s kind of a ‘heads up’ to apartment and condo managers to better take care of property in dire weather. If the temperature drops to a certain degree, snow can freeze and then it becomes like an ice skating rink on walkways and sidewalks. Snow is usually not as feared as much as ice, just due to unpredictability because you don’t know where the slick spots are on an icy path. Going back to the court case, Cuiyan Qian sued Villas at Cranbury Brook Homeowners Association because of a slip and fall that was attributed to unsafe sidewalks on the property. The case was then thrown out due to tort liability, or the fact that the sidewalks were deemed public and associations are not liable for such injuries. But the state Supreme Court reversed the lower court’s decision, saying the Villas — in their own business governing documents — had a duty to upkeep the sidewalks for residents. Also, the Villas collected money from residents as a means of taking care of the elements and the grounds.

And even with no easement to protect the property from non-residents, the Villas was still burdened with the responsibility. Also, the Villas maintained liability insurance for injuries sustained, further demonstrating that they took full responsibility for the sidewalks. Ultimately, after the court considered the fact that the sidewalks were owned, maintained, controlled and insured by the Villas, it made its determination upon the premise that “residential public-sidewalk immunity does not apply in the case of a sidewalk privately owned by a common-interest community. Who owns or controls the sidewalk, not who uses it, is the key distinguishing point between a public and private sidewalk.” In determining ownership, the Supreme Court opined that “(a) critical factor in determining whether a sidewalk is ‘public’ is whether the municipality has sufficient control over or responsibility for the maintenance and repair of the sidewalk.”

Condominiums and homeowners’ associations are impacted by such a decision going forward because of maintenance responsibilities and insurance policies. This is language written into the fabric of a legal binding agreement, and must be overlooked and possibly overhauled if necessary for the benefit of the property and the residents. Going forward, the timely removal of snow combined with an association’s negligence during any season — not just the winter — is important and necessary to show due diligence as an ownership body. Items like checks and cleanup history could be important if a certain property holder is ever sued, as it would show such diligence is taking place. Managers should converse with attorneys in an attempt to create logical yet informative agreements between properties and residents, and so a situation doesn’t come up like the one that impacted the Villas.

Building Smarter

Subscribe for Project Insights & Updates

Get the latest tips, project highlights, and financing updates delivered straight to your inbox. Stay ahead with expert guidance from Lemus Construction for multi-family and commercial properties.

Related articles

Tom D.
4 years ago
Lemus replaced the roofing on our three church buildings. Work was done promptly, quickly and completely. We are very satisfied.
Response from the owner:Hi Tom, we appreciate the fantastic review and are overjoyed at the success of this project. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know!
Martin B.
9 years ago
Response from the owner:Martin, thanks for the rating! We are pleased you had a positive experience.
Chappy H.
5 years ago
Excellent roofing compqny
Response from the owner:Hi Chappy, thank you for your feedback! We are proud to have been able to give you a pleasant experience.
Kyle B.
3 years ago
Absolutely thrilled with the window installation and painting services provided by Lemus Construction! From start to finish, the process was seamless and professional. Mike and his team arrived promptly, worked efficiently, and paid meticulous attention to detail. Our new windows not only look fantastic but have significantly improved energy efficiency. Additionally, the painting job transformed our space, with flawless results that exceeded our expectations. Communication was excellent throughout, and the crew left the site clean and tidy. I highly recommend Lemus Construction for their top-notch craftsmanship and exceptional customer service!
Response from the owner:Kyle! Thanks for taking the time to share your review of our services! Your feedback is invaluable in helping us provide the best service for our clients. We really appreciate you taking the time to help us grow!
Roxanne
4 years ago
This is the 3rd time we have worked with Lemus for a new roof. Very happy with their work. Professional and efficient. We found a couple of things that needed to be tweaked, and they did not hesitate to take care of them ASAP. I highly recommend them.
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for your continued loyalty Roxanne! We are always at your service.
Lisa S.
1 year ago
I can’t say enough good things about Chris, JJ and the contractors who replaced my roof. Chris showed up at 7am to accommodate my work schedule, had a quote to me within a couple of hours and answered any and all questions. JJ was amazing at sharing the progress and issues that were found, took care of remediating everything and finished timely. The area was clean of debris. He pulled the permits for me, worked with my HOA and was available for any question
Response from the owner:We can’t thank you enough for this wonderful review. Chris and JJ always go above and beyond to make sure our homeowners feel supported throughout the entire roofing process. It’s great to hear everything from scheduling to cleanup was handled to your satisfaction and we'll be sure to pass along your good graces to the team. Thanks for choosing Lemus!
Howard A.
9 years ago
Professional, good prices and workmanship that is second to none! Everyone is friendly and work gets done on time and on budget.
Response from the owner:Hi Howard, we strive to provide the highest level of service possible. Thank you for taking the time to share your experience!
Rob S.
4 years ago
We are very happy with the work Lemus recently did at our house. The siding job looks great and added value to our home.
Response from the owner:Hi Rob, we are incredibly grateful that you took the time out to leave us a positive review. Your satisfaction is what makes all the hard work worth it!
Pamela T.
4 years ago
Lemus Construction is top notch. Their integrity, dedication, hard work and attention to detail shows in all their completed projects. They are always friendly and reliable which is an added bonus. I can't say enough great things about this company. They take the worry out of hiring a contractor.
Response from the owner:Hi Pamela, Thank you so much for this 5-star review. We really appreciate you being a loyal collaborator and helping to share the word about us. We’re here for you anytime.
Henry R.
1 month ago
Great company kudos to Annette and chris service is there middle name
Response from the owner:Thanks Henry! Always a pleasure!
Bernie O.
1 year ago
Lemus approach to our GLV Roofing Project has been spot on from daily management to workers endurance in exceptional heat, especially on the roofs when the heat registered at 130 degrees. I can verify that my Copperfield neighbors came to the aid of Ken’s roofers and ground help. We refilled Gatorade, lemonade, watermelon, cookies, zucchini loaf and even had a chance to treat all of the ground crew to warm sandwiches of BBQ and salad. The crew is respectful and considerate and they clean up every evening. This is just my message but I am sure so many other folks feel so much the same way.
Response from the owner:Hi Bernie, thank you so much for your kind words. We’re thrilled to hear that you’re satisfied with our work and management on the GLV Roofing Project. It’s great to know the crew’s hard work and endurance didn’t go unnoticed, especially in those extreme heat conditions. We appreciate the community support from Copperfield neighbors—it truly makes a difference for our team. Thanks again for your thoughtful feedback!
Esperanza M.
4 years ago
I replaced all my windows, and they did an excellent job. Super, dependable family-owned company. I highly recommend Lemus Construction. The estimate was done by the owner and he stayed right on target. They crew is very skilled. They were efficient, responsive and easy to communicate with. Our windows look amazing! It feels like we are in a brand-new house. Thank you Lemus.
Response from the owner:Hi, Esperanza. We are thrilled that you had a positive experience with us! Thank you so much for the kind words.
Craig B.
5 years ago
Good work and service
Response from the owner:Craig, thank you for taking the time to provide your feedback! Let us know if we can ever be of further service to you.
Many M.
3 years ago
Great contractor! They strive for customer service and quality work!
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re thrilled to hear our team’s focus on customer service and quality made a difference. It was a pleasure working with you, and we truly appreciate your support!
Peter S.
3 years ago
Our Management firm has worked with Lemus on various projects over the last 10 years, ranging from full roof and siding replacements on multi-family Condominiums (consisting of 246, 184, 136, and 76 units) to structural facade renovations, window replacements, roof repairs, and everything in between. Not only have we at RCR Management been extremely satisfied with their work quality and response time, but so have the many unit-owners we represent. This company is built on a strong foundation of respectful and caring people, which starts at the top with Victor and Mario. We highly recommend them for any exterior project you may be considering!
Response from the owner:Peter, Thanks for taking the time to submit a great review! Your feedback means the world to us and we really appreciate your kind words. It's always great to receive recognition and your support is invaluable.
Mikhail S.
6 months ago
Update: Lemus Construction came back today and took care of everything. They replaced the wall panel and installed all new window screens of good quality. The team was professional, polite, and completed the work properly. We appreciate that they followed up and resolved the issue. Everything is now in good condition, and we have no further concerns. Thank you for taking care of it. Original review: We had a very disappointing experience with Lemus Constructions during a roof replacement project in our community. It was clear that the workers lacked experience—things were constantly falling, and they caused multiple damages. They broke our deck (which, to their credit, was later repaired), damaged our house wall, and also damaged the front gutter, which now doesn't divert water properly. Additionally, almost all of our window insect screens were torn. When we raised these issues, we were told that they had warned us to remove or protect everything ourselves. Some screens are at a height we simply can't reach, and they aren't easy to remove. In the end, they made it clear that we, the homeowners, are fully responsible, and they bear no accountability. No compensation was offered, and they refused to engage in further conversation. While they were great at selling their services and getting into our community, the actual work seemed to be done by the cheapest, unskilled labor. Everything that could go wrong, did. I strongly advise avoiding this company—if they damage your property, they will not take responsibility, and the quality is awful.
Response from the owner:Thank you for updating your review, Mikhail. We appreciate the opportunity to work through your concerns and glad we were able to bring everything to a positive resolution. Thank you for your patience throughout the process and for recognizing the efforts of the crew. We appreciate your updated feedback and are happy to hear everything is now in good condition. Original Response: Hi Mikhail, thank you for taking the time to share your concerns. We understand this situation has involved a lot of back and forth specific to your home, and we recognize that construction work can feel disruptive to daily life. We’ve been made aware of your concerns, have had several conversations with your community management team, and continue to discuss possible options and next steps regarding the items brought to our attention. As you stated, residents were notified prior to construction, where possible, due to the nature of roofing debris, winds, and vibration during installation. These notices are standard throughout the roofing industry and were provided to help minimize the risk of incidental damage during the project. We will continue communicating with you while reviewing the additional concerns raised against our pre construction documentation, as well as coordinating with your HOA board members and working within the scope and responsibilities outlined through the community’s contracted agreements and hope to come to a satisfying conclusion for an updated review.
Patty B.
4 years ago
The staff at Lemus was great to work with. I would recommend them. Great communication and very accommodating.
Response from the owner:Hi, Patty. Thanks for taking the time to share your positive experience with our staff. We all truly appreciate it!
Gamboa C.
2 years ago
Response from the owner:Hi Gamboa, Thank you for your 5 star review! We’re so proud of what we do, and it’s amazing to know that our hard work was noticed and valued. We can't express our gratitude enough.
Joe A.
1 year ago
Response from the owner:Hi Joe, thank you for the 5-star rating! We appreciate you taking the time to support our team—your feedback means a lot.
Eileen G.
4 years ago
I am a member of the board for an adult condo community. It was time to replace the roofs/gutters and trim. A MASSIVE project. We vetted 6 vendors. We interviewed, read proposals, asked questions, etc etc. LEMUS continually impressed us with their professionalism, responsiveness and cooperation. We are halfway through a 2 year project. The residents can't say enough positive things about the management, crew, etc. They are honest and VERY easy to work with. Go LEMUS
Response from the owner:Hi Eileen, we are tremendously grateful for your positive feedback! We hope to continue serving you and appreciate you taking the time to share your rating with us.
B S.
2 years ago
The crew from Lemus replaced three difficult roof cut out boxes on two of the hottest days of the year. They did an amazing job. This is the third time I have used their company and I can’t rate them highly enough. I’d like to give them six stars!!
Response from the owner:Hello B, Thanks for the awesome review. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and leaving such an amazing review. Your kind words mean the world to us!
Greivin F.
7 years ago
Response from the owner:Thank you for your rating Greivin!
Fran H.
1 year ago
We had a disastrous situation by a previous contractor (I'd love to name them but won't) on our commercial roof. We were expecting a full replacement would be needed. Victor met with us on site. We walked the entire roof and he pointed out the problem spots and explained in detail, the work that would be needed to remedy our issues. His estimate was very fair and he was up front about some potential additional work that might be needed that could not be determined at the time of the survey. Those costs came in at a minimum when the work was done. Lemus's professionalism & craftsmanship was incredible from the start of the process to the end. Our issues are completely resolved and we are no longer worried every time it rains!
Response from the owner:Hi Fran, we’re so happy to hear this feedback! From the start, our goal was to provide you with a clear, honest assessment of your commercial roof and create a repair plan that would last. Victor’s walkthrough, pointing out problem spots and explaining the process, is exactly how we strive to keep homeowners and property owners informed every step of the way. We’re proud that our roofing team delivered quality craftsmanship that not only fixed the issues but also brought back your peace of mind. You’ve been a pleasure to work with, and we’re truly grateful for your support and trust in Lemus Construction.
MANNY
4 years ago
Outstanding service and Professionalism!
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us a 5 star rating - it's much appreciated!
Michelle S.
3 years ago
Excellent to work with from start to finish! True craftsmen! Very professional- beautiful job!
Response from the owner:Hi Michelle! Thank you for leaving a review. We are honored and humbled by your kind words and look forward to being your go-to for future construction projects you may have.